Samsung's Earnings Beat Splits Analysts on Target Price
Samsung Electronics reported roughly 57 trillion won in operating profit for Q1, followed by about 89 trillion won in Q2. In the quarterly operating-profit chart going back to 2015, these two quarters stand out sharply, splitting opinion over whether this is a temporary spike or the start of a new earnings regime.
Kiwoom Securities became the first domestic brokerage to cut its Samsung target price, from 430,000 won to 390,000 won, citing slowing EPS growth in the second half alongside rising expectations for HBM4 market-share gains and intensifying competition from Chinese memory makers. Hyundai Motor Securities, by contrast, kept its target at 440,000 won, with a report titled, memorably, 'Its only sin is earning too much and rising too much.'
Morgan Stanley argued that the narrow, semiconductor-led rally is winding down and recommended trimming memory names like SK hynix in favor of hyperscalers. The hosts called out a circular-logic flaw in the report: it assumes the AI ecosystem isn't over while telling investors to rotate out of chips into hyperscalers — companies whose fortunes ultimately still depend on chip demand. They also questioned the bank's credibility given its prior 'Winter Is Coming' memory-downturn call, which it walked back with an apology months later, and the fact that SK hynix reportedly excluded Morgan Stanley from the underwriting syndicate for its planned U.S. listing.