Column
[Kwangsoo's Take] Sound Reasoning and Accountability Before Hasty Trading
Lee Kwang-soo said that limiting losses is important in a sharp downturn and that investors with an excessive allocation to stocks could consider reducing it. He stressed, however, that acting hastily without reaching a conclusion about the market's direction is risky. Buying new shares and deciding what to do with existing holdings are different questions, and he made clear that he was not recommending holding stocks simply because prices might rise.
Lee said he had encouraged more people to invest for the long term on the belief that the Korean stock market would improve, and emphasized the responsibility that comes with offering investment guidance. Investors should act only after assessing whether the uptrend will continue or turn into a downtrend. He said he would examine the situation carefully rather than rush to a conclusion, and provide investors with a clear answer.
He advised investors responding to a downturn to first consider not only what to do, but also what not to do. Rather than being swept up in sharp declines and rebounds, borrowing money or rushing to trade, investors should focus on weathering uncertainty while volatility remains high. The KOSPI has fallen 20% over a period of about a month on five occasions in the past 16 years, and investors have experienced three of those episodes in less than a year. He said investors need to recognize how unusual the current market environment is.
Park Si-dong, speaking in a personal capacity, said Samsung Electronics and semiconductor stocks had fallen far below their intrinsic value. Based on the previous day's closing price, he calculated Samsung Electronics' dividend yield at 6.4–8%, and argued it could rise to around 9% if the share price fell a further 10%. Comparing the current low multiples of semiconductor stocks with the KOSPI's historical price-to-earnings ratio of about 10 times, he interpreted them as reflecting excessive market expectations of weaker earnings next year. He forecast that continued earnings growth and improvements in shareholder returns could convince the market.
Park said cumulative net foreign selling since the start of the year had exceeded KRW 230 trillion, and suggested that profit-taking by investors who bought at lower prices and a shift in semiconductor preferences could be behind the selling. In a Korean market heavily weighted toward Samsung Electronics and SK Hynix, selling in those stocks amplifies declines in the index. He also said selling pressure from investors who bought at 7,000–8,500 could prompt foreign investors to remain on the sidelines. He cited a slowdown in foreign selling, a recovery in semiconductor demand, increased dividends and share cancellations by companies, and improved domestic market flows as conditions for a return of buying.
It was argued that the government and political establishment also have an important role to play in restoring confidence in the Korean market. Park called for policy messages to support investor sentiment, citing market reforms, efforts to revitalize the KOSDAQ, amendments to the Commercial Act, outreach to overseas investors, and the participation of market-stabilization funds and retirement pensions in the market. Lee also said that stock markets grow when investors, companies and government policy all move together. He expressed hope that political and policy attention would follow corporate changes such as higher dividends and share cancellations.